A man who had tried both extremes sat down under a tree. He had been raised in a palace with every comfort arranged around him, and he left it still searching. He then spent years with five companions in severe austerity, eating so little that, in his own account, when he reached to touch his belly he took hold of his spine. He left that life too, with the same hunger, so he set both extremes aside, took some rice and porridge, and stayed seated until something changed.
Where the teaching was first given
He gave his first teaching in a deer park. He traveled by stages from Uruvela to Isipatana, the place now called Sarnath, outside Varanasi, to find the same five men who had left him in disgust when he gave up starving himself. They saw him coming and agreed among themselves to give him no greeting, yet as he drew near, they could not keep to it. He taught them in turns, two at a time while three went out for alms food, until all five were free.
That first talk survives as the Dhammacakkappavattana Sutta, “Setting the Wheel of Dhamma in Motion,” recorded in the Pali canon at Samyutta Nikaya 56:11. It dates to approximately the fifth century BCE. A sutta is a teaching of the Buddha, from the Pali word for “thread,” the same word as the Sanskrit sutra.
Its four truths rest on what anyone can observe, and the teaching asks only to be tested. The gods appear at the end, as an audience spreading the news. It has the shape of a medical examination: the condition, its cause, whether it can be cured, and the treatment.
A teaching built this way asks one thing of you: to check it. A diagnosis puts something in front of you and invites you to see whether it is true, whoever said it.
He built it that way because he was pointing at something already happening inside every person listening, something each of them could confirm alone.
That is also why the fourth truth is a course of treatment, something you carry out and then judge by its results. The instruction he gave the Kalama people, later in this article, says so in his own words.
The first truth: everything passes
The Pali word is dukkha, usually translated “suffering,” which makes the teaching sound bleaker than it is. Closer to the sense of it is unsatisfactoriness — the quality of slipping away. Things arrive, and then they leave.
The sutta lists the obvious forms: being born, growing old, dying, sorrow, grief, being stuck with what you dislike, being parted from what you love, and being denied what you want. Another short discourse, the Rahogata Sutta, adds something subtler. There the Buddha says “whatever is felt” belongs to dukkha, because every feeling is inconstant. Pleasant experience counts too, because it ends, and part of us knows that even while it lasts.
If you have read Happiness – Everyone's Dilemma, you have met this already. The rewards we chase are real yet temporary, and their fading sends us out after the next one. The Buddha's first truth is that same observation, made twenty-five centuries earlier and given a name.
The second truth: the cause has a name
The Buddha did not attribute the condition to fate, to sin, or to the will of anything. He gave it a cause: tanha, a word that means thirst.
Thirst here is the reaching itself: the movement of mind that wants more of an experience, less of it, or a different one. The sutta names three kinds: thirst for sensual pleasure, for becoming something, and for ceasing to be.
Here is the line that matters most, the one easiest to read past. If thirst is the cause, it lives inside you, and this is the hope of the whole teaching: whatever you carry, you can change.
The third truth: the thirst can end
The third truth is one word, nirodha, meaning cessation: remove the thirst, and the suffering it produces goes with it. In a physician's terms this is the prognosis, the outlook for the patient.
It is worth being exact about what ends, because the word cessation has frightened people for centuries.
What ends is the thirst. You remain, along with your life, your work, your family and your pleasure in all of it. The food still tastes good, and the music is still music. The people you love are now loved better. What stops is the ache underneath them, the part of the mind that grips a good thing and already dreads its end.
The world stays whole, and the way you meet it changes.
The state that remains is called nibbana in Pali and nirvana in Sanskrit, a word meaning going out, as a flame goes out. The image is precise, because a fire lasts as long as it is fed. When the burning stops, the lamp remains, and the room is still warm.
So the third truth is the moment the chase is called off, along with the plain discovery that what you were chasing was there the whole time, once you stopped running past it.
The Vedic texts call this state by other names. The Taittiriya Upanishad calls it ananda, bliss, and says that Brahman, the source from which all beings are born, is bliss. The Maitri Upanishad calls freedom from “This is I” and “That is mine” moksha, liberation. Christian, Sufi and Kabbalist writers reach for the same thing in their own words. The apostle Paul wrote of “the peace of God, which passeth all understanding.” The Sufi writer al-Hujwiri wrote of fana, the passing away of every blameworthy quality of the self. In Kabbalah the word is devekut, cleaving to God, and Isaac of Acre wrote of reaching it while still living. The Common Thread running between them holds, whatever the language.
The fourth truth: there is a road
Having named the condition, the cause and the cure, the Buddha gave the treatment: the Noble Eightfold Path, eight strands of one rope, worked on together. The eight fall into three trainings, and the first, wisdom, holds two of them:
- Right view — seeing the four truths as they are.
- Right intention — the resolve toward non-harming and letting go.
The second training, conduct, shapes how you live among others:
- Right speech — speech that is true, kind, brings people together, and has a purpose.
- Right action — protecting life, taking only what is given, and keeping faith in sexual conduct.
- Right livelihood — earning a living through honest, harmless work.
The third, training of the mind, works on attention itself:
- Right effort — turning the mind away from what damages it and toward what strengthens it.
- Right mindfulness — steady awareness of body, feeling, mind and their contents.
- Right concentration — the gathered, steady attention built through meditation.
In English the word right can sound like a scolding, yet the Pali samma means something nearer to complete, or well-aligned, the way a wheel runs true on its axle. It describes a fit.
Where to begin
Start with one, and let it teach you the others.
- Right speech is the one available every hour. For a single day, say only what is true and kind. It is harder than it sounds.
- Watch the thirst. Next time you want something, notice the wanting: where it sits in the body, how long it lasts, what it promises. That is the second truth, observed first-hand.
- Steady the attention. Concentration is trained, and the breath is the place to start. See Pranayama: Ancient Breath Control Techniques for the methods behind it.
- Read the source. The Dhammacakkappavattana Sutta takes ten minutes, and you can read the whole discourse free here, in Thanissaro Bhikkhu's translation.
The Buddha's instruction to the Kalama people was to test a teaching against their own experience: keep what proves skillful, and set aside what proves harmful. Twenty-five centuries later, the offer stands.
Sources
- Dhammacakkappavattana Sutta — Samyutta Nikaya 56:11, Pali canon. The first discourse, given at the deer park at Isipatana (Sarnath). Read it free at Access to Insight, translated by Thanissaro Bhikkhu.
- Kalama Sutta — Anguttara Nikaya 3:65, on testing a teaching against one's own experience. Read it free.
- Maha-Saccaka Sutta — Majjhima Nikaya 36, the Buddha’s own account of his years of austerity and why he abandoned them.
- Ariyapariyesana Sutta — Majjhima Nikaya 26, his journey to the five monks at Isipatana. Rahogata Sutta — Samyutta Nikaya 36:11, “whatever is felt.”
- Taittiriya Upanishad 3.6 and Maitri Upanishad 6.30, in Robert Ernest Hume’s translation, The Thirteen Principal Upanishads. Philippians 4:7, King James Version.
- Al-Hujwiri, Kashf al-Mahjub, translated by Reynold A. Nicholson, on fana. Encyclopaedia Judaica, “Devekut,” on Isaac of Acre.